Prompt and Model
Building with AI

EU Inc proposal faces pushback as Council mandate weakens key provisions

Startup advocacy groups are urging the European Commission to withdraw and re-table the original EU Inc proposal, warning that the Council's negotiating mandate has gutted critical provisions like free registration choice and a central EU register, risking a standard founders will not use.

Startup advocacy groups are urging the European Commission to withdraw and re-table the original EU Inc proposal, warning...

Advocacy groups Startups for Europe and EU-INC have called for the withdrawal of the EU Inc proposal due to Council mandate changes that undermine its core purpose. The groups called on European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen to withdraw the proposal and table it again in its original form. They warn that proceeding to final trilogue negotiations risks further compromises rather than restoring provisions already lost.

The campaign, backed by more than 26,000 co-signatories, announced the demand at the Slush conference in Helsinki. The groups remain strong supporters of the European Commission’s original proposal after two years of campaigning for a single European company standard. They judge the proposal by one simple test: whether a founder would choose it over incorporating as a Delaware C-Corp in the United States. The Commission's original proposal passes that test. The Council's mandate does not.

If the proposal continues on its current course, Europe risks adopting an EU Inc that founders won't use. The call follows a joint letter to President von der Leyen reaffirming support for the Commission's original proposal and urging member states to reconsider their positions.

Council mandate weakens key provisions of EU Inc

The Council’s negotiating mandate of 19 October weakened or removed several provisions critical to founders. The changes position the EU standard less favorably against the US benchmark.

ProvisionChange in Council Mandate
Free choice of registrationWeakened
Central EU registerRemoved, leaving 27 national registers in place
Simplified insolvency rulesRemoved
Employee stock optionsRestricted to companies with up to 750 employees or €150 million turnover

These alterations strip away the simplicity and uniformity that the original proposal promised. The employee stock option scheme is now limited, and the system reverts to a fragmented landscape of national registers.

Founders warn of Delaware incorporation shift

Co-initiators of the campaign warn that the stripped provisions will push founders to incorporate in Delaware instead of using EU Inc. Andreas Klinger, an investor and co-initiator of EU-INC, stated that founders need a company structure that makes it easier to build, raise capital and scale across Europe. He warned that stripping away key provisions will cause founders to incorporate elsewhere.

Simon Schaefer, President of Startups for Europe and co-initiator of EU-INC, added that member states must put Europe's collective interests ahead of national compromises to ensure EU Inc delivers on its original promise. The groups warned that proceeding directly to final trilogue negotiations risks further compromises and a standard founders will not use. Employees hoping for stock options will face eligibility limits tied to company size and turnover under the current Council mandate.

Commission's original proposal remains viable alternative

The EU Inc proposal was presented by the Commission in March and aims to create a single European company standard. It is designed to offer an alternative to Delaware incorporation in the United States. The Commission delivered a solid framework that could give European founders a genuine alternative and allow companies to start and scale under one common European standard.

In September, President von der Leyen warned against turning EU Inc from a speedboat into a heavy tanker. The fate of EU Inc now depends on whether the Commission restores the provisions that the Council removed or accepts them in the upcoming trilogue negotiations.

Uncertain Commission response to withdrawal request

The Commission's response to the withdrawal request remains unknown. The executive body has not yet indicated whether it will act on the call to withdraw and re-table the proposal. The future of the EU Inc standard now hinges on the Commission's decision to either fight for the restoration of the original provisions or accept the Council's changes in the forthcoming trilogue negotiations.

Related coverage

More from Building with AI